| Platinum | Eddies Calzones |
| Gold | Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza |
| Silver | Baumhower's Victory Grille |
| Bronze | Pizza Hut |
| Top Pick | Hungry Howie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Little Caesars |
| Top Pick | Little Italy Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Lost Pizza |
| Top Pick | Marco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mellow Mushroom Auburn |